The Call
Your cousin, who has just turned 18, turns up at your door at midnight. She’s left her strict parents’ home; they’ve never hurt her, but she says she can’t breathe there, and she begs you not to tell them where she is. An hour later, her mother calls you, sobbing, and asks: ‘Is she with you?’ If you say no, the mother will spend the night searching the streets. If you say yes, they’ll put your cousin under tremendous emotional pressure to return.
Do you tell her?
The Nudge
Two strong pushes, one each way. Neither is the answer.
For “Tell her the truth”
Her mother is sobbing on the phone, asking a simple question. If you lie, she’ll spend the whole night searching the streets, imagining the worst. She’s never hurt her daughter. She’s done nothing to deserve that night. Your cousin is safe on your sofa, and telling her mother where she is doesn’t send her back; it only stops her mother’s terror. One honest word and a frightened woman can sleep. Can you really hang up and leave her out there in the dark?
For “Say she isn’t here”
Your cousin is 18, an adult, and she came to your door at midnight because she trusted you. She begged you, once. Say yes, and by morning her parents will be pressing her to come home, to the place she says she can’t breathe. The very first night she reached out for help, will you hand her back? Her mother will be frightened, and that’s real. But your cousin will remember for the rest of her life whether the first person she trusted kept her secret. Who else will she ever turn to?
Press and hold your answer for two seconds.
Committed. In Torn, you’d now predict whether most people chose as you did, and then see the world’s split.
Play the full dilemma in Torn