The Library
Every past dilemma, and the thinkers behind it.
Each day Torn asks one moral dilemma. Once a day has closed, it comes here: the question, both sides at full strength, why it’s hard, and the philosophers who have argued about it. There are no right answers, only reasons.
Dilemmas
5 past daysThe Exam
Do you report her?
Loyalty and safetyNo. 004 · 2 November 2026The Phone
Do you report it?
Rules and mercyNo. 003 · 1 November 2026The Hire
Who do you hire?
Family or meritNo. 002 · 31 October 2026The Marking
Do you report it?
Merit and luckNo. 001 · 30 October 2026The Promise
Do you sell?
Deathbed promisesThinkers
All 99 thinkersFrom Confucius and Plato to Hannah Arendt and Peter Singer: who they were, and the ideas that still pull us one way or the other.
Confucius
551–479 BCEChinese teacher (551–479 BCE) whose sayings in the Analects place family duty, ritual and caring for others at the heart of a good life.
Plato
c. 428–348 BCEAthenian philosopher, student of Socrates and teacher of Aristotle, whose Republic asks what justice is and why we should be just.
Aristotle
384–322 BCEGreek philosopher (384–322 BCE) who saw the good life as flourishing through virtue, with each virtue a mean between extremes.
Epicurus
341–270 BCEGreek philosopher (341–270 BCE) who taught that the good life is freedom from pain and worry, and that death is nothing to us.
David Hume
1711–1776Scottish philosopher who held that reason alone cannot move us to act, that morality rests on feeling, and that our generosity is limited.
Immanuel Kant
1724–1804German philosopher of the categorical imperative, who held that we must never treat people merely as a means.
John Rawls
1921–2002American philosopher of justice as fairness, who asked what rules we would choose behind a veil of ignorance.
Sir Bernard Williams
1929–2003British moral philosopher who challenged utilitarianism with ideas of integrity, one thought too many and moral luck.
Pythagoras
c. 570–c. 495 BCEGreek thinker of the 6th century BCE who founded a strict community with rules for living and taught that the soul survives death.