Today’s dilemma

Library · No. 001 · 30 October 2026

The Promise

Deathbed promises

Content note: This one involves the death of a parent.

Your dying father made you promise never to sell the house he built. Your sister lives there and can't buy you out. You're deep in debt, working two jobs, barely seeing your kids. Your half would clear everything.

Do you sell?

  • Keep the promise
  • Sell the house

The Nudge

One push for each side, the strongest case we could make for both.

For “Keep the promise”

It was the last thing your father ever asked of you, and you said yes while he was dying. And your sister lives in that house. Force a sale and you break his trust and pull her home out from under her in the same move. Confucius said you see who a child really is after the father dies: whether they keep to his ways. The debt is crushing, but debts can be worked off. A promise to a dying father can never be taken back. When you're old yourself, will you want to have struggled a few more years, or broken your word the moment it got hard?

For “Sell the house”

You're working two jobs, drowning in debt, and your children barely see you. Half that house is legally yours, and your half would clear everything. Your father loved you, and he loved his grandchildren. Do you really believe he meant that promise to keep them without their parent? Epicurus taught that death is nothing to us: your father can no longer be hurt by a sale. Your children can be hurt by your absence. Your sister has a home; your kids have these years, now, and they'll only get them once. Will you tell them one day that you chose bricks over bedtime stories?

Drawing on Confucius and Epicurus.

How the world split

36% Keep the promise64% Sell the house

Final result, fewer than 100 answers. Shares are rounded to whole percentages; exact counts are never published.

Why it’s hard

Your word to your father and your sister's home against your children's need for you. W. D. Ross (1930) said we have several real duties at once, such as keeping promises and helping others, and must weigh them case by case; none always wins. T. M. Scanlon (1990) argued that breaking a promise wrongs the person who relied on it, and here your sister relies on it too. George Pitcher (1984) argued that the dead can be wronged, so your father's trust still counts. Would your father, seeing your children now, release you from it?

The pull of “Keep the promise”

You gave your word to your father as he died, and your sister's home rests on it. Forcing a sale would break both his trust and her life in one move.

The pull of “Sell the house”

Your children need their parent back, and you're drowning. Half the house is legally yours, and your father surely didn't mean his promise to sink his grandchildren.

The thinkers

  • W. D. Ross · 1930Held that we have several prima facie duties, such as fidelity and beneficence, that must be weighed when they conflict.
  • T. M. Scanlon · 1990Argued that breaking a promise wrongs the person who was led to rely on it.
  • George Pitcher · 1984Argued that the dead can be wronged; betraying them harms the person they were before they died.

Sources and further reading

  • Scanlon, T. M. (1990). Promises and Practices. Philosophy & Public Affairs, 19(3), 199-226.
  • Ross, W. D. (1930). The Right and the Good. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
  • Pitcher, G. (1984). The Misfortunes of the Dead. American Philosophical Quarterly, 21(2), 183-188.

This dilemma ran on 30 October 2026. Like every Torn dilemma, it was tested by our readers and approved by the editors before it ran. Spotted a mistake?Report an error.