Today’s dilemma

Library · No. 002 · 31 October 2026

The Marking

Merit and luck

You got the last place on your dream course. Then you spot a marking mistake in your favour. Report it, and the place goes to Sam from your class, who missed by one mark after nursing her sick mother all year.

Do you report it?

  • Report the mistake
  • Keep the place

The Nudge

One push for each side, the strongest case we could make for both.

For “Report the mistake”

That place was never yours. A marking error put you there, and Sam, who spent the whole year nursing her sick mother, missed by a single mark. Plato told of a ring that made its wearer invisible, and asked whether anyone stays honest when nobody can see. This is your ring. Keep quiet and you'll start your dream course knowing, every single day, whose seat you're sitting in. Will the dream still feel like yours? Reporting it hurts now, but you'll have done it honestly. If the error had gone the other way, you'd be begging someone to say something.

For “Keep the place”

You worked for this. Years of effort got you within reach, and the mistake wasn't yours: you didn't ask for it and you didn't cause it. Aristotle held that we're praised or blamed for what we do willingly, not for what simply happens to us. Nobody would ask Sam to hand back a lucky mark if the error had gone her way. Sam's year was hard, and that's genuinely sad, but sad isn't the same as owed. Why should you give up something you may never get back, to fix a mistake you didn't make?

Drawing on Plato and Aristotle.

How the world split

20% Report the mistake80% Keep the place

Final result, fewer than 100 answers. Shares are rounded to whole percentages; exact counts are never published.

Why it’s hard

What fell to you against what Sam earned. John Rawls (1971) argued that nobody deserves their starting point in life, so a fair system shouldn't simply reward good luck. Michael Sandel (2020) warned that treating success as pure merit makes winners proud and losers humiliated. Here the mistake was luck in your favour, and Sam's year was hard luck against her. But you worked too, and the error wasn't yours. Is keeping a place won through someone else's mistake the same as taking it?

The pull of “Report the mistake”

Sam earned it while nursing her mother. The mark that got you in isn't yours.

The pull of “Keep the place”

You worked for this, and the mistake wasn't yours. Giving up your dream for a marking error isn't something anyone can demand.

The thinkers

  • John Rawls · 1971Argued that nobody deserves their natural talents or starting point, so justice shouldn't simply reward luck.
  • Michael Sandel · 2020Criticised the belief that success is purely earned, for making winners proud and losers humiliated.

Sources and further reading

  • Rawls, J. (1971). A Theory of Justice. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
  • Sandel, M. J. (2020). The Tyranny of Merit. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux.

This dilemma ran on 31 October 2026. Like every Torn dilemma, it was tested by our readers and approved by the editors before it ran. Spotted a mistake?Report an error.