You're supervising a final exam. A ringing phone means automatic failure. Last week you failed a boy whose phone rang with a call from his gran's care home. Today a girl's phone buzzes: the hospital where her mother is. Everyone heard.
Do you report it?
- Report the phone
- Let it go
The Nudge
One push for each side, the strongest case we could make for both.
For “Report the phone”
Last week you failed a boy for exactly this. His reason was just as heartbreaking: a call from his gran's care home. Kant said to act only on a rule you could want everyone to follow. Let this girl off in front of the whole room, and the rule becomes: it bends for whoever's story is saddest. Everyone heard the phone. Everyone is watching what you do. If she walks away free, he was punished for nothing. Are you ready to tell him his gran mattered less than her mother?
For “Let it go”
Her mother is in hospital. She didn't touch the phone; it buzzed. Report it and she loses a whole year because a hospital tried to reach her. Aristotle saw that rules are written for the usual case, and that fairness sometimes means correcting them where they misfire. Yes, you failed a boy last week; if that was unfair, put his right instead of repeating it on her. Nobody in that room thinks she was cheating. Will you really make a frightened girl pay for your need to look consistent?
Drawing on Immanuel Kant and Aristotle.
How the world split
Final result, fewer than 100 answers. Shares are rounded to whole percentages; exact counts are never published.
Why it’s hard
Treating like cases alike against mercy for a girl who did nothing wrong. Aristotle called the correction of a rule where it fails a particular case 'equity', and thought it part of justice. John Rawls (1955) distinguished justifying a practice from justifying an act within it: once you hold the role, the rule may not be yours to reopen. Your choice last week makes this harder, because letting her go makes his failure look unjust. Is the right thing to be consistent, or to be merciful now and try to put last week right?
The pull of “Report the phone”
You failed a boy last week for the same thing, with just as good a reason. Letting her off in front of everyone makes that unjust.
The pull of “Let it go”
Her mother is in hospital, and she didn't touch the phone. Making her repeat a year for that would be cruel.
The thinkers
- Aristotle · c. 340 BCECalled the correction of a rule where it fails a particular case 'equity', and held it to be part of justice.
- John Rawls · 1955Distinguished justifying a rule-governed practice from justifying a particular act within it.
Sources and further reading
- Aristotle. Nicomachean Ethics, Book V, ch. 10 (on equity).
- Rawls, J. (1955). Two Concepts of Rules. Philosophical Review, 64(1), 3-32.
This dilemma ran on 2 November 2026. Like every Torn dilemma, it was tested by our readers and approved by the editors before it ran. Spotted a mistake?Report an error.