You're hiring for one job. Your sister, out of work a year, is about to lose her flat. She'd do it well. A stranger is clearly the stronger candidate, raising two kids alone on nothing. Nobody would know you're related.
Who do you hire?
- Hire your sister
- Hire the stranger
The Nudge
One push for each side, the strongest case we could make for both.
For “Hire your sister”
Your sister is about to lose her home. You've watched her struggle for a whole year, and now the one thing that could stop it is sitting on your desk. She'd do the job well. Maybe not best, but well. David Hume saw nothing shameful in caring most for those closest to us: it's how human kindness works. If family doesn't mean pulling each other out when one of you is sinking, what does it mean? The stranger's need is real, but she isn't your sister. Can you picture telling your sister you had a job to give, and gave it to someone else?
For “Hire the stranger”
The stranger is clearly the better candidate, and she's raising two children alone on nothing. She earned this job on merit. John Rawls asked us to choose our rules as if we didn't know which person we'd turn out to be. If you could be the sister or the struggling mother, which rule would you want: the best candidate wins, or whoever knows the boss? Nobody would know, which is exactly why this is a test of who you are. Fairness doesn't mean much if it only lasts until it costs your family.
Drawing on David Hume and John Rawls.
How the world split
Final result, fewer than 100 answers. Shares are rounded to whole percentages; exact counts are never published.
Why it’s hard
Your sister's home against a fair choice for a stranger just as desperate. William Godwin (1793) argued that impartial justice ignores who is related to whom. Bernard Williams (1981) replied that a life without special loyalties loses much of what gives it meaning. Simon Keller (2013) asked where reasons of partiality come from, and argued they come from the people we love themselves. Hiring adds a twist: the job isn't yours to give away, and your employer trusts you to pick the best candidate. Can you favour family with something that isn't yours?
The pull of “Hire your sister”
Your sister is about to lose her home, and she'd do the job well. Standing by family when they're sinking is what family is for.
The pull of “Hire the stranger”
The stranger is clearly better, and her children depend on her. Choosing your sister would be unfair to a woman just as desperate.
The thinkers
- William Godwin · 1793Argued that impartial justice ignores ties of family when deciding whom to benefit.
- Bernard Williams · 1981Argued that deep personal commitments give life meaning and can't simply be overridden by impartial reasons.
- Simon Keller · 2013Explored the grounds of partiality and argued that its reasons come from the value of the people we love.
Sources and further reading
- Godwin, W. (1793). An Enquiry Concerning Political Justice, Book II, ch. 2. London: G. G. J. and J. Robinson.
- Williams, B. (1981). Persons, Character and Morality. In Moral Luck: Philosophical Papers 1973-1980. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
- Keller, S. (2013). Partiality. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
This dilemma ran on 1 November 2026. Like every Torn dilemma, it was tested by our readers and approved by the editors before it ran. Spotted a mistake?Report an error.