Today’s dilemma

Thinkers · c. 477–524

Boethius

Roman scholar who, awaiting execution, wrote The Consolation of Philosophy on fortune, true happiness and whether God's foreknowledge leaves us free.

Boethius was a Roman nobleman and scholar who lived in Italy under Theoderic, the Ostrogothic king who ruled from Ravenna. He set out to translate the works of Aristotle into Latin and explain them, and his books on logic became the main way people in western Europe learned the subject for centuries. Late in life he became one of Theoderic's chief officials, but he was accused of treason, imprisoned and executed.

In prison he wrote The Consolation of Philosophy, a mix of prose and poetry. In it, Philosophy appears to him as a woman and talks him through his despair. She reminds him that Fortune is always changing, like a turning wheel: wealth, power and fame can be lost at any moment, so they were never truly his. Real happiness, she argues, lies in goods that bad luck cannot take away, such as virtue, and finally in God, the highest good.

The book also asks a famous question: if God already knows everything we will do, are we still free? Philosophy's answer is that God is eternal, seeing all of time at once, so his knowledge does not force our choices. The Consolation became one of the most widely read books of the Middle Ages.

Where it comes up on Torn

  • Can outcomes beyond our control change how blameworthy we are?

Sources

Drafted with AI assistance, checked against the sources above and approved by the editors. Spotted a mistake? Report an error.