Today’s dilemma

The Library

The thinkers.

The philosophers our dilemmas draw on, roughly in order of when they lived. Each page says who they were and what they argued, in plain English.

Back to the Library

Pythagoras

c. 570–c. 495 BCE

Greek thinker of the 6th century BCE who founded a strict community with rules for living and taught that the soul survives death.

Confucius

551–479 BCE

Chinese teacher (551–479 BCE) whose sayings in the Analects place family duty, ritual and caring for others at the heart of a good life.

Heracleitus

c. 535–c. 475 BCE

Greek thinker from Ephesus, around 500 BCE, who saw the world as constant change held together by a hidden order.

Parmenides

early 5th c. BCE

Greek thinker of the early 5th century BCE who argued that true reality is one and unchanging, and that reason must judge over the senses.

Zeno of Elea

c. 490–c. 430 BCE

Greek thinker of the 5th century BCE, a younger associate of Parmenides, famous for paradoxes such as Achilles and the tortoise.

Socrates

470–399 BCE

Athenian philosopher (470–399 BCE) who questioned everyone about how to live and chose to accept his death sentence rather than escape.

Democritus

c. 460–c. 370 BCE

Greek thinker from Abdera, born around 460 BCE, who taught that everything is made of atoms and that the goal of life is cheerfulness.

Plato

c. 428–348 BCE

Athenian philosopher, student of Socrates and teacher of Aristotle, whose Republic asks what justice is and why we should be just.

Aristotle

384–322 BCE

Greek philosopher (384–322 BCE) who saw the good life as flourishing through virtue, with each virtue a mean between extremes.

Mencius

c. 372–c. 289 BCE

Chinese Confucian thinker of the 4th century BCE who argued that human nature is good, as anyone seeing a child near a well can feel.

Zhuangzi

c. 369–c. 286 BCE

Chinese thinker of the 4th century BCE whose playful stories, like the butterfly dream, question fixed viewpoints and fixed roles.

Pyrrhon of Elis

c. 360–c. 270 BCE

Greek thinker (c. 360–c. 270 BCE) who taught that we should hold back from firm opinions, and that calm follows.

Epicurus

341–270 BCE

Greek philosopher (341–270 BCE) who taught that the good life is freedom from pain and worry, and that death is nothing to us.

Zeno of Citium

c. 334–c. 262 BCE

Thinker from Cyprus who founded Stoicism in Athens around 300 BCE, teaching that virtue is the only true good.

Philo Judaeus

c. 20 BCE–c. 50 CE

Jewish thinker of Alexandria (c. 20 BCE–c. 50 CE) who read the Hebrew scriptures in the light of Greek philosophy.

Marcus Aurelius

121–180

Roman emperor (121–180) and Stoic whose private notebook, the Meditations, reflects on duty, death and our place in the whole.

Nagarjuna

c. 150–c. 250

Indian Buddhist monk (c. 150–c. 250) who taught that nothing has a fixed, independent nature, and founded the Middle Way school.

Plotinus

204/5–270

Philosopher (204/5–270), born in Egypt and teaching in Rome, who taught that all things come from the One and the soul can return to it.

Sextus Empiricus

c. 2nd–3rd c.

Greek sceptic and doctor of the 2nd or 3rd century whose books are our fullest record of ancient Pyrrhonian scepticism.

Saint Augustine

354–430

North African bishop and philosopher (354–430) whose Confessions and City of God shaped Christian thinking on sin, love, lying and war.

Hypatia

c. 355–415

Mathematician, astronomer and Platonist philosopher who led a school in Alexandria and became a lasting symbol of learning and independent thought.

Boethius

c. 477–524

Roman scholar who, awaiting execution, wrote The Consolation of Philosophy on fortune, true happiness and whether God's foreknowledge leaves us free.

Śaṅkara

c. 700–750

Indian philosopher of Advaita Vedānta, who taught that the deepest self in each of us is one with Brahman, the single ultimate reality.

al-Kindī

c. 800–870

Known as the philosopher of the Arabs, he argued that Greek philosophy and Islam could work together and that truth should be welcomed wherever it comes from.

al-Fārābī

c. 870–950

Called the Second Teacher after Aristotle, he described a virtuous city led by a ruler who is both philosopher and prophet.

Avicenna (Ibn Sīnā)

980–1037

Persian physician and philosopher whose Floating Man thought experiment asks whether we could know we exist without any awareness of our bodies.

Rāmānuja

c. 1017–1137

South Indian philosopher of qualified non-dualism, who taught that selves and the world are real, related to God as a body to its soul, and stressed devotion.

Ibn Gabirol

c. 1021–c. 1058

Jewish poet and philosopher of Muslim Spain whose Fountain of Life taught that everything, even the soul, is made of matter and form.

Saint Anselm

1033–1109

Monk and Archbishop of Canterbury, famous for the ontological argument and the motto faith seeking understanding.

al-Ghazālī

1058–1111

Theologian and mystic who left a top teaching post after a personal crisis and challenged the philosophers in The Incoherence of the Philosophers.

Peter Abelard

1079–1142

Brilliant medieval logician who argued that what makes an act right or wrong is the intention behind it, not its outcome.

Averroës (Ibn Rushd)

1126–1198

Judge, physician and philosopher from Córdoba, known as the Commentator on Aristotle, who argued that true philosophy and religion cannot conflict.

Zhu Xi

1130–1200

Chinese Neo-Confucian who taught that by investigating things we come to know their principle, and so cultivate our naturally good character.

Moses Maimonides

1138–1204

Jewish philosopher, physician and legal scholar, author of the Guide for the Perplexed, known for his eight levels of charity.

Ibn al-ʿArabī

1165–1240

Andalusian Sufi thinker who taught that only God truly exists and that everything else is a manifestation of that one reality.

Shinran

1173–1263

Japanese Pure Land Buddhist who taught that we are saved not by our own merit but by entrusting ourselves to the compassion of Amida Buddha.

Saint Thomas Aquinas

c. 1225–1274

Medieval friar who joined Christian teaching with Aristotle, the classic thinker of natural law and the source of the doctrine of double effect.

John Duns Scotus

c. 1266–1308

Scottish Franciscan, the Subtle Doctor, who stressed the freedom of the will and the thisness that makes each individual unique.

William of Ockham

c. 1287–1347

English Franciscan behind Ockham's razor, the principle that we should not assume more things exist than we need to explain what we observe.

Niccolò Machiavelli

1469–1527

Florentine diplomat whose The Prince argued that a ruler must learn how not to be good, while his Discourses praised free republics.

Wang Yangming

1472–1529

Ming dynasty Chinese philosopher, official and general who taught that knowing and acting are one: to truly know the good is to do it.

Francis Bacon

1561–1626

English lawyer, statesman and philosopher who argued that knowledge should be built on observation and experiment, and used to improve human life.

Thomas Hobbes

1588–1679

English philosopher whose Leviathan argued that without government life would be a war of all against all, so people agree to obey a sovereign.

René Descartes

1596–1650

French philosopher and mathematician who doubted everything he could and found one certainty: I think, therefore I am.

John Locke

1632–1704

English philosopher of natural rights, property, toleration and government by consent, who linked personal identity to consciousness and memory.

Benedict de Spinoza

1632–1677

Dutch philosopher, expelled from Amsterdam's Jewish community, who saw God and Nature as one and freedom as understanding why things happen.

Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz

1646–1716

German polymath who co-invented calculus and argued that God chose to create the best of all possible worlds.

Giambattista Vico

1668–1744

Neapolitan philosopher who held that we truly know only what we make, and that history moves through repeating ages.

George Berkeley

1685–1753

Irish philosopher and bishop who argued that there is no matter apart from minds: to be is to be perceived.

Montesquieu

1689–1755

French writer whose The Spirit of the Laws argued for separating the powers of government so that power can check power.

David Hume

1711–1776

Scottish philosopher who held that reason alone cannot move us to act, that morality rests on feeling, and that our generosity is limited.

Jean-Jacques Rousseau

1712–1778

Genevan writer of The Social Contract who held that people are naturally good but corrupted by society, and who confessed his own wrongs.

Immanuel Kant

1724–1804

German philosopher of the categorical imperative, who held that we must never treat people merely as a means.

Moses Mendelssohn

1729–1786

German-Jewish Enlightenment philosopher whose Jerusalem argued that no state or religion should force anyone's beliefs.

Condorcet

1743–1794

French mathematician and philosopher who studied the logic of voting and campaigned for equal rights for women and an end to slavery.

Jeremy Bentham

1748–1832

English founder of utilitarianism, who judged actions by the happiness they produce and argued that what matters is whether a being can suffer.

G. W. F. Hegel

1770–1831

German philosopher who argued that we become ourselves through recognition by others, and saw history as the growth of freedom.

Arthur Schopenhauer

1788–1860

German philosopher who saw life as driven by a blind will to live, and made compassion the basis of morality.

Auguste Comte

1798–1857

French founder of positivism who coined the words sociology and altruism and later founded a Religion of Humanity.

John Stuart Mill

1806–1873

English philosopher of On Liberty and Utilitarianism, who set out the harm principle and argued for equality between women and men.

Søren Kierkegaard

1813–1855

Danish thinker (1813–1855) who explored faith, anxiety and choice, and asked what it means to become a real self.

Karl Marx

1818–1883

German philosopher and economist (1818–1883) who wrote about alienated labour, class and how economic life shapes history.

Herbert Spencer

1820–1903

English thinker (1820–1903) who applied the idea of evolution to society and ethics and coined the phrase survival of the fittest.

Wilhelm Dilthey

1833–1911

German philosopher (1833–1911) who asked how we understand other people's lives, and how the humanities differ from the natural sciences.

William James

1842–1910

American philosopher and psychologist (1842–1910) who championed pragmatism and defended our right to believe when proof runs out.

Friedrich Nietzsche

1844–1900

German philosopher (1844–1900) who questioned traditional morality and urged people to create their own values and affirm their lives.

Gottlob Frege

1848–1925

German mathematician and philosopher (1848–1925) who founded modern logic and showed that meaning has two sides: sense and reference.

Edmund Husserl

1859–1938

Founder of phenomenology (1859–1938), who urged philosophers to describe experience exactly as it shows itself.

Henri Bergson

1859–1941

French philosopher (1859–1941) who contrasted lived time with clock time and saw life as a creative, unfolding force.

John Dewey

1859–1952

American philosopher and educator (1859–1952) who championed learning by doing and saw democracy as a whole way of life.

Alfred North Whitehead

1861–1947

English mathematician and philosopher (1861–1947) who saw reality as a process of becoming rather than a collection of fixed things.

Benedetto Croce

1866–1952

Italian philosopher (1866–1952) who saw art as the expression of intuition and history as the story of human freedom.

Nishida Kitarō

1870–1945

Japanese philosopher (1870–1945) who founded the Kyoto School and joined Zen insight with Western philosophy.

Bertrand Russell

1872–1970

British philosopher and logician (1872–1970) who transformed logic, questioned induction and was jailed for opposing the First World War.

G. E. Moore

1873–1958

English philosopher (1873–1958) who argued that good cannot be defined and defended the certainty of common sense.

Martin Buber

1878–1965

Austrian-born Jewish philosopher (1878–1965) whose I and Thou contrasts truly meeting others with treating them as things to use.

Ludwig Wittgenstein

1889–1951

Austrian-British philosopher (1889–1951) who argued that the meaning of a word lies in its use within shared activities, or language games.

Martin Heidegger

1889–1976

German philosopher (1889–1976) who explored what it means to exist, facing death and living authentically rather than following the crowd.

Rudolf Carnap

1891–1970

German-born philosopher (1891–1970) and leading logical positivist, who asked which statements can be meaningful and how science is built.

Sir Karl Popper

1902–1994

Austrian-British philosopher (1902–1994) who said scientific theories must be falsifiable and defended the open society.

Theodor W. Adorno

1903–1969

German Frankfurt School thinker who criticised the culture industry and asked how to think and live after the Holocaust.

Jean-Paul Sartre

1905–1980

French existentialist who held that existence precedes essence: we have no fixed nature and are responsible for what we make of ourselves.

Hannah Arendt

1906–1975

German-American political thinker who wrote of the banality of evil and saw forgiveness and promising as remedies for the risks of action.

Simone de Beauvoir

1908–1986

French existentialist and author of The Second Sex, who argued that one becomes a woman and that our freedom depends on others' freedom.

W. V. O. Quine

1908–2000

American logician who pictured our beliefs as a web, where any belief can be revised but some are much harder to give up than others.

Sir A. J. Ayer

1910–1989

British logical positivist whose emotivism held that moral statements express feelings rather than facts that could be true or false.

Wilfrid Sellars

1912–1989

American philosopher who contrasted the everyday manifest image of the world with the scientific image and sought to join them.

John Rawls

1921–2002

American philosopher of justice as fairness, who asked what rules we would choose behind a veil of ignorance.

Thomas S. Kuhn

1922–1996

American historian of science who argued that science changes through paradigm shifts, not just the steady piling up of facts.

Michel Foucault

1926–1984

French historian and philosopher who studied how power works through watching, examining and normalising people, using the Panopticon as a model.

Noam Chomsky

b. 1928

American linguist who argued that humans are born with a capacity for language, a universal grammar shared by all languages.

Jürgen Habermas

b. 1929

German philosopher of discourse ethics: a moral rule is valid only if all those affected could agree to it in fair, open discussion.

Sir Bernard Williams

1929–2003

British moral philosopher who challenged utilitarianism with ideas of integrity, one thought too many and moral luck.

Jacques Derrida

1930–2004

French philosopher of deconstruction who argued that a true gift and pure forgiveness seem to be possible only as the impossible.

Richard Rorty

1931–2007

American pragmatist who doubted philosophy could find final foundations and held that cruelty is the worst thing we do.

Robert Nozick

1938–2002

American philosopher who defended rights as side constraints and a minimal state, and invented the experience machine.

Saul Kripke

1940–2022

American logician whose Naming and Necessity argued that names pick out the same thing in every possible world.

David Kellogg Lewis

1941–2001

American metaphysician who argued that other possible worlds are real, and explained how conventions arise without agreement.

Peter Singer

b. 1946

Australian utilitarian philosopher of the drowning child and Animal Liberation, who argues for equal consideration of interests.