Today’s dilemma

Thinkers · 1079–1142

Peter Abelard

Brilliant medieval logician who argued that what makes an act right or wrong is the intention behind it, not its outcome.

Peter Abelard was born around 1079 at Le Pallet in Brittany, in north-west France. He gave up his inheritance in order to study, and became one of the most brilliant and argumentative teachers in Paris. His love affair with Héloïse, a gifted scholar, ended in scandal and violence; afterwards both entered religious life, he as a monk and she as a nun. Their letters, and his autobiographical The Story of My Troubles, are still read today. Church councils condemned some of his theological writings during his lifetime.

In logic and metaphysics he was an early nominalist: he argued that universals, general terms such as human or red, are words rather than real things existing in the world. In his book Sic et Non (Yes and No) he set conflicting statements by church authorities side by side and showed how to reason through them.

His ethics, set out in a book called Know Yourself, puts intention at the centre. What makes an act right or wrong, he argued, is not its outcome, nor even our desires, but our inner consent to what we do. He gives the example of two men who each plan to build a shelter for the poor, but one is robbed before he can do it. Abelard thought it absurd to judge one man better than the other.

Where it comes up on Torn

  • Can outcomes beyond our control change how blameworthy we are?

Sources

Drafted with AI assistance, checked against the sources above and approved by the editors. Spotted a mistake? Report an error.