Today’s dilemma

Thinkers · 1929–2003

Sir Bernard Williams

British moral philosopher who challenged utilitarianism with ideas of integrity, one thought too many and moral luck.

Sir Bernard Williams (1929–2003) was a British moral philosopher, born in Essex and educated at Balliol College, Oxford. He was one of the leading thinkers about ethics in the late 20th century. He worked in Britain and then, from 1987, at the University of California, Berkeley, before returning to Oxford in 1990 as White's Professor of Moral Philosophy. He was knighted in 1999. His books include Moral Luck (1981) and Ethics and the Limits of Philosophy (1985).

Williams was a sharp critic of utilitarianism, especially in Utilitarianism: For and Against (1973), written with J. J. C. Smart. In one example George, a chemist who badly needs work, is offered a job researching chemical and biological weapons, which he thinks deeply wrong. If he refuses, someone keener will take it. Williams argued that simply adding up outcomes ignores George's integrity: his deepest commitments are part of who he is, not just one more item to be weighed.

He also argued that impartial rules can distort ordinary love. If a man saves his wife rather than a stranger, and first checks that morality allows it, he has had one thought too many: it should be enough that she is his wife. And with moral luck he pointed out that how we judge people, such as a painter who leaves his family to pursue his art, can depend on how things turn out, which is partly beyond their control.

Where it comes up on Torn

  • May I favour my own people?
  • Am I responsible for what others do because I refused?
  • Can outcomes beyond our control change how blameworthy we are?

Dilemmas that draw on Sir Bernard Williams

Sources

Drafted with AI assistance, checked against the sources above and approved by the editors. Spotted a mistake? Report an error.