Today’s dilemma

Thinkers · c. 1266–1308

John Duns Scotus

Scottish Franciscan, the Subtle Doctor, who stressed the freedom of the will and the thisness that makes each individual unique.

John Duns Scotus takes his name from Duns, a village in Scotland near the English border, where he was born. He became a Franciscan friar and taught at Oxford, Paris and Cologne, where he died in 1308. His arguments were so finely drawn that he became known as the Subtle Doctor.

He is famous for his idea of haecceity, or thisness. Two things can share the same nature: two dogs are both dogs. What makes this dog this particular dog, rather than any other, is its own individual thisness. He also argued that words such as good and wise can be used in the same sense of God and of creatures.

In ethics, Scotus gave the will a central place. A free choice, he held, requires that at the very moment of choosing we could have chosen otherwise, and freedom belongs to the will itself rather than coming from the intellect's judgement. On morality, he thought only a few moral truths, such as that God must not be hated, are strictly necessary. Most of the commandments, including those about how we treat each other, depend on God's free will and belong to natural law only in a looser sense. His approach shaped later debates about free will and about how far morality depends on God.

Sources

Drafted with AI assistance, checked against the sources above and approved by the editors. Spotted a mistake? Report an error.