Today’s dilemma

Thinkers · c. 1225–1274

Saint Thomas Aquinas

Medieval friar who joined Christian teaching with Aristotle, the classic thinker of natural law and the source of the doctrine of double effect.

Thomas Aquinas was born around 1225 near Aquino, in southern Italy. As a young man he joined the Dominicans, a new order of preaching friars, even though his family tried to stop him by confining him for a year. He taught theology in Paris and in Italy and died in 1274. His greatest work, the Summa Theologiae, which he left unfinished, brings Christian teaching together with the philosophy of Aristotle. He was declared a saint in 1323.

Aquinas believed that reason can show some truths about God, such as God's existence, while other truths need revelation. In ethics he is the classic thinker of natural law. Because we are rational, we can grasp what is truly good for human beings, such as life, knowledge and friendship. The first principle of practical reason is that good is to be done and pursued, and evil avoided; more detailed moral rules follow from it.

Two of his ideas are still widely debated. Discussing self-defence, he argued that a person may use force that they foresee might kill an attacker, as long as they intend only to stop the attack; later thinkers developed this into the doctrine of double effect. He also held that private property is justified, but that in urgent need, when there is no other way, taking what one needs is not theft, because in such need all things are common.

Where it comes up on Torn

  • Does desperate need override property rights?
  • Is killing worse than letting die? Does intending harm differ from foreseeing it?

Sources

Drafted with AI assistance, checked against the sources above and approved by the editors. Spotted a mistake? Report an error.